Alt Investments

Advising Investors And Collectors Of Gold

Matthew Erskine November 3, 2022

Advising Investors And Collectors Of Gold

This brief commentary explains the sort of considerations that investors and advisors should entertain before holding gold. In the current high-inflation environment, gold is understandably getting attention.

For centuries, gold has held the status of money, and has been a safe-haven asset. Much to the frustration, perhaps, of some economists and champions of modern central banking fiat currencies, gold retains its appeal. When inflation runs into double-digit rates and central banks digitally create, or "print," vast amounts of money, as has been the case for more than a decade, it is easy to make the case for gold as ballast, or insurance in a portfolio. But the devil is in the detail. Gold can sometimes be quite closely correlated to more mainstream assets, such as during a broad-based market panic; in the past gold has also been confiscated by governments (such as under the F D Roosevelt administration in the 1930s). 

Whatever the caveats, gold is around in financial markets for a reason. To discuss these matters is regular commenter in these pages, Matthew Erskine, managing partner at his law firm Erskine & Erskine. (See a previous example of Matthew's writing here.) The editorial team are pleased to share these views and invite readers to join the conversation. The usual editorial disclaimers apply to views of guest writers. Email

Recently a CEO client of mine sent me this email:

“Hi Matt, 

Do you know anything about investing, buying and selling gold? Who to deal with? Etc.?


The fact is, I know very little about buying, selling or investing in gold. I do know that the presence of gold among the assets of a client that I am giving tax and estate planning advice to raises many questions. The most important one is are you are an investor or a collector? The next most important thing is to find out their goal. Is it investing, collecting or both? It is important to know the difference between collecting and investing or just being a hobby. 

Investing in gold: Investors buy gold as a hedge against the rise of inflation, the fall of the stock market or the change in the strength of the dollar. The two common ways of investing in gold is to hold gold indirectly, either through a fund that holds gold directly, for example the Gold ETF (ticker symbol GLD); or hold stock in companies that mine and refine gold, such as Barrick Gold (ticker symbol ABX), or directly by buying bullion, either in the form of coins or bars. 

As with any investment, you need to weigh the risks and the rewards. The risk of indirect investment in gold is that your investment is not only subject to the market risks of the rise and fall of the price of gold, but also the industry risk and the possible fees charged in a fund. The risk of direct investment in bullion is that when you decide to sell the bullion, you may find the fees charged by the broker are quite high. Gold does not produce a dividend, and there is the risk of higher federal capital gains tax on bullion (28 per cent + 3.8 per cent) over that of the sale of the stock or fund units (20 per cent + 3.8 per cent).

Collecting gold: Although there are many stories of people who acquired gold numismatics, (gold coins that have a higher-value than just the metallic weight), for a song and sold for a king’s ransom, this is not how a serious collector purchases gold. Collectors buy both because they work hard to make the best deal that they can on buying or selling coins and because they are passionate about the coins they do collect.  

Passion can come from a personal connection to the coins. Often collectors try to create a “type” collection that is a complete collection of all of the coins of a certain classification or type. For American gold coins, the types include $1, $2.50 (a quarter-eagle), $3, $4, $5 (a half-eagle), $10 (an eagle), and $20 (a double eagle). In each type, there are some years and varieties which are more common and some that are less common (if not unique). The rarer coins are called Key Coins and they command a vast premium over the more common coins. 

When a collector’s hard work, knowledge and diligence pays off with the acquisition of such a key coin, especially for a good price, it is the stuff that long tales (if not tall tales) are made of. 

There are some people who start out investing in bullion, who then get “the bug” and start collecting numismatics. My experience is that the serious investor is no more reluctant to sell bullion than they would be for any other investment. On the other hand, serious collectors are reluctant to part with a collection, especially with their Key Coins.  

The advice investors need is how to minimize or avoid the income taxes on buying or selling. For a collector the issue is how to preserve the collection and to avoid selling, either to pay estate taxes or meeting the financial needs of themselves or their family. So, if you are thinking about buying gold, define for yourself, whether you want to be an investor or a collector? Once you can answer this, then ask yourself what your goal is?  

The answer to these two questions will determine the type of estate and tax planning to best address your needs.

Register for FamilyWealthReport today

Gain access to regular and exclusive research on the global wealth management sector along with the opportunity to attend industry events such as exclusive invites to Breakfast Briefings and Summits in the major wealth management centres and industry leading awards programmes