Alt Investments
Navigating Private Investments: A Guide for Financial Advisors
As access into private market investments evolves, there are fewer excuses for wealth managers not to consider their place in clients' portfolios, the author of this guest article says.
Wealth managers will now be familiar with the arguments for why they should give clients exposure – within certain risk and liquidity constraints – to private market investments such as private credit and equity, for example. What remains less understood, perhaps, is a complex landscape of how these investments work, and how to access them. As part of our continued examination of investment issues in September, here is a guest analysis by Joseph DaGrosa, Jr, (pictured) chairman and CEO of Axxes Capital, which is based in Coral Gables, Florida. The editors are pleased to share these views; the usual disclaimers apply. Email tom.burroughes@wealthbriefing.com if you want to respond.
Over the past 12 months, you’ve no doubt become aware of the push
to provide private market assets to a broader range of investors
– maybe you’ve read articles, discussed it at conferences,
explored the asset class yourself, or have even had clients ask
you about the potential opportunities in private investments and
how they could fit into their portfolios.
In speaking with several RIAs, and as a former financial advisor
myself, I understand the challenges you may be facing when
considering this or any new asset class and, more
importantly, explaining new opportunities to your clients. Here’s
what you need to know to have a better understanding of private
market allocations, have those discussions with your clients and
potentially take the next step in allocating to private market
investments.
Why private markets? Why now?
What is your biggest concern when it comes to advising your
clients? It’s a question I often asked myself as a financial
advisor, and still routinely ask my RIA colleagues. While there
are the usual fears – selling or buying at the wrong time,
missing opportunities, etc – the issue that comes up most
often is ensuring that clients’ assets outlast their lifespan, a
significant concern as the average 50-year-old today will likely
live three years longer than their counterpart of thirty years
ago.
Quite simply, private investments can help solve this issue. They
are not just a new opportunity for a bit of extra alpha but can
instead mitigate the risk of outliving assets by enhancing
returns, providing more diversification and lowering volatility
versus a traditional public market portfolio. Private assets
represent a sizable investible market, with assets under
management totaling an estimated $16.3 trillion in 2023. That
pool has grown nearly 20 per cent per annum since 2018 and is
expected to reach $24.5 trillion by 2028.
These opportunities are well understood by leading institutions,
private foundations and ultra wealthy investors. For long-term
and patient investors, there is considerable return potential in
the private sector, as well as significant benefits to further
diversification away from public markets, especially during
selloffs or corrections.
Moreover, there is a concern that the return on public equities
will not be as strong in the future as in the past. According to
FactSet, the S&P 500 forward PE [price-to-earnings] multiple
has risen from nearly 10x in 2009 to over 20x in
2024. Assuming that earnings growth over the next 15 years
is similar to the past 15 years, the multiple would have to rise
to almost 40x for the S&P 500 to repeat its performance,
assuming similar earnings growth. This is highly unlikely and
therefore suggests that one should consider a new approach to
investment allocation. If public market multiples remain steady
or contract in the future, returns could be up to 50 per cent
lower than previous levels.
Some may claim that private investments may have reached their
peak and therefore have no place in a traditional portfolio.
However, what this argument is missing is that the private
market, like the public, is not a monolith. Private market
strategies offer tremendous breadth across strategies including
private equity growth/expansion, buyouts, venture capital
(including pre revenue, post revenue and pre-IPOs), private debt,
real estate, infrastructure and others. Given the scope, scale
and variety across investment styles, these strategies offer
tremendous diversification benefits versus traditional equity
markets.
Addressing client concerns
Of course, even if private market investments may benefit clients
over the long-term, they nonetheless may be reluctant to engage
due to the traditional perception of the sector – that it is
difficult to access, illiquid and the exclusive purview of the
ultra rich.
However, these concerns are often due to a lack of knowledge on
the breadth of private market opportunities, the role they play
in a diversified portfolio, the important contribution they can
make in mitigating the risk of outliving assets and the
increasing the ability to easily gain access to private
investments. I have found that the following information can help
put clients' concerns at ease:
1) Significant opportunity set – The size of the
private markets is often misunderstood. According to Capital IQ,
there are 7x more US private companies than public companies
with annual revenues of $100 million-plus, all of which depend on
investible private market solutions. Moreover, companies are
staying private twice as long as they did two decades ago,
meaning that more high-quality firms are inaccessible through
public equity and debt.
2) Extensive investment options – Like the public
markets, which are made up of various financial instruments and
approaches, so too are the private markets. Large private equity
deals and venture capital raising in Silicon Valley may get the
headlines, but they are only a component of what’s available.
Private equity, private debt and venture capital can each play a
role in a portfolio, and like the mix of stocks and bonds, so too
should private allocations be diversified based on client
objectives, comfort level and knowledge. While each client is
different, depending on their age, portfolio size and risk
tolerance, a good starting point is around 10 per cent to 20 per
cent in private markets with allocations across equity credit and
real estate.
3) Benefits of further diversification – Private
equity strategies offer different risk-return profiles and
varying correlations versus public securities. Lower correlations
can offset risk within a traditional equity portfolio. For
example, per Capital IQ correlations between the S&P 500 and
the Russell 2000 small cap index, mid-cap and Nasdaq stocks
usually run near 0.9 (1.0 being a perfect correlation), meaning
that prices move up and down together very closely and very
often. As a result, investor diversification often reduces risk
offset. By comparison, private equity strategies correlate around
0.75, venture capital near 0.5 and secondaries near 0.25 when
compared with the S&P 500, thereby offering significantly
lower correlation and therefore better diversification benefits
when added to traditional public market equity portfolios.
4) Long-term focus – Private investors are
strategic long-term investors and, most frequently, bring
significant industry, product and executive expertise to bear on
portfolio companies. Unlike public markets, private investors are
not exposed to momentum, algorithmic investing, meme stock runs,
short-term traders or hedge fund strategies that are based on
non-fundamental, short-term considerations. Private investors are
also unencumbered by passive index investors that are purposely
unaware of stock-specific or idiosyncratic considerations.
5) Client suitability – To be fair, not all clients
will benefit outright from private investments, especially if
they are older. But considering expected longer life spans and
the role private investments can play over the longer term, those
clients with a potential remaining lifespan of 20 years or more
could see considerable advantages with some allocation to private
investments. Moreover, younger generations, who are seeing the
greatest wealth transfer in history, may not only be best suited
for additional private exposure but are in fact more open to the
possibilities. A recent Bank of America survey found that
investors aged 21 to 42 versus their age 43+ counterparts
are more likely to: 1) “Agree or strongly agree that it’s not
possible to achieve above-average returns solely with traditional
stocks and bonds” and 2) “Say private equity is an investment
that offers the greatest opportunity for growth.”
6) Evolving access – New products and services are
removing the barriers for accredited investors to participate in
the private markets. Once only available to large institutions or
the ultra wealthy, private investments are now available through
a range of financial vehicles that have low investment minimums,
ticker symbols with daily subscriptions, daily net asset value,
and quarterly redemptions. And when tax time comes around, new
products offer simplified 1099 reporting, greatly improving
efficiency for investors, advisors and tax preparers. However,
perhaps the greatest innovation is the potential elimination of
subscription documents for certain types of registered private
investment vehicles (ex: interval funds). This will undoubtedly
make it much easier for financial advisors to reallocate into
private investments for those of their clients for which it is
suitable.
While private investments come with their own set of risks, the
real risk for financial advisors may lie in overlooking
opportunities that could significantly enhance client portfolios.
By grasping the value of private assets and effectively
communicating their advantages, advisors can help clients achieve
a well-diversified and resilient portfolio that stands the test
of time.