Family Office
Harrisdirect sale to bolster BMO’s wealth business

Canadian bank says it’ll use proceeds to target U.S. private
clients. Canada’s BMO Financial Group has agreed to sell
Harrisdirect , its U.S. discount-brokerage unit, so it
concentrate on providing wealth-management services to U.S.
clients. The Toronto-based company says the sale was prompted by
a desire to sidestep an increasingly tight and expensive race in
the discount arena while using funds from the transaction to
invest in more lucrative business lines.
BMO – better known as the Bank of Montreal – will sell
Harrisdirect to E-Trade, a New York-based discount broker, for
$700 million in cash. BMO will get another $50 million from
Harrisdirect once the deal is done. Harrisdirect has about
430,000 active accounts and $32 billion in assets under
administration. The transaction has nothing to do with BMO
InvestorLine, BMO’s Canadian discount brokerage unit.
Way out
“The decision to sell Harrisdirect followed an assessment of
[its] ability to compete in a changing landscape,” says BMO’s
president and CEO Tony Comper. “Given the additional amount of
capital that would have been required to grow the business and
remain competitive in the current environment of consolidation,
we concluded that Harrisdirect would be more valuable to another
participant in the online brokerage industry.”
A conspicuous element in the “environment of consolidation” is
Ameritrade’s planned acquisition of rival online brokerage TD
Waterhouse, made public less than two months ago. That came after
Ameritrade spurned an offer from E-Trade. Discount brokers, which
saw their valuations soar in the dot-com craze of the late 1990s,
thudded back to earth in the market downturn of 2000-2002. Price
cuts and smaller commissions in the face modest equity returns
since then have done little to improve their fortunes.
While some online brokers see fusion as a way out of their
problems, others have increased their efforts to cater to
high-net-worth clients. San Francisco-based Charles Schwab, the
biggest discounter, bought U.S. Trust in 2000 as a way “to serve
the investment and wealth management needs of investors at every
stage of their financial growth,” according to an old press
release. Schwab is also the biggest service agent to independent
registered investment advisors. And it’s far from lonely in its
pursuit of high-net-worth wallet share. Wirehouses, regional
brokers, banks of all sizes and a host of boutiques have piled
into wealth management in recent years. All of them are looking
for a reliable and sticky revenue streams for helping a growing
demographic of well-heeled clients plan for their retirements or
manage their estates, depending, more or less, on how wealthy
they are.
For its part, BMO sees ditching Harrisdirect as a way to
strengthen its push into that arena. “This transaction increases
value to our shareholders and will allow us to redeploy capital
to higher-return businesses and to concentrate our attention on
our goal of becoming the leading personal and commercial bank in
the U.S. Midwest,” says Comper.
New focus
And Comper’s colleague Bill Downe, BMO deputy chairman and head
of BMO Nesbitt Burns, the bank’s traditional brokerage business
in Canada, makes it clear that wealth management figures
prominently in BMO’s plans. “Wealth management will continue to
be an integral part of our overall personal and commercial-led
U.S. strategy,” he says.
Downe sees the private bank of BMO’s Harris unit, a Chicago-based
regional bank, as its wealth-management flagship in the U.S.
“Harris Private Bank has an excellent reputation, strong brand
recognition and an attractive customer base,” he says. “Wealth
management is a profitable, high-growth industry and we believe
we are well-positioned to participate in this growth.” But BMO
isn’t volunteering specific insights into its expansion
plans.
In addition to its private bank, Harris also owns Redwood City,
Calif.-based Harris myCFO, a multi-family office, and Sullivan,
Bruyette, Speros & Blayney, a financial planning firm based in
McLean, Va. –FWR
Purchase a reprint of this story.